[Updated with table 05/17/12 8:25 AM EDT ]

There were 15 lists compiled in this consensus.

Top 5

captdallas.........(Tavares, Hamonic, Okposo, Bailey, Grabner)
since70too.........(Tavares, Hamonic, Strome, Okposo, Bailey)
NorthDakotaRedEagle(Tavares, Hamonic, Grabner. Strome, Poulin)
martylnd...........(Tavares, Hamonic, Donovan, strome, Nelson)
BaltimoreIslander..(Tavares, Hamonic, Strome, Poulin, Okposo)
JPinVA.............(Tavares, Hamonic, Bailey, Okposo, Strome)
MarkKrugman........(Tavares, Hamonic, Niederreiter, Strome, Okposo)
AfroSupreme........(Tavares, Hamonic, Grabner, Okposo, Strome)
shanamaj...........(Tavares, Hamonic, Okposo, Grabner, Poulin)
Metzfan22..........(Tavares, Hamonic, Okposo, Strome, Grabner)
ChairmanMeow.......(Tavares, Strome, Hamonic, Niederreiter, Okposo)
Sayvillelax94......(Tavares, Hamonic, Strome, Grabner, Okposo)
BenHasna...........(Tavares, Hamonic, Okposo, Bailey, Grabner)
Dougtone...........(Tavares, Hamonic, Grabner, Okposo, Strome)
EDavidMorris.......(Tavares, Hamonic, Strome, Poulin, Okposo)


Table after the jump...

RANK PLAYER (POINTS)| The point system is 25 for 1st, 24 for 2nd, 23 for 3rd...
1. John Tavares (375)
HIGH: 1(ALL)
LOW: 1 (ALL)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2009/1
2011 LHH 25U25: 1

2. Travis Hamonic (359)
HIGH: 2(14)
LOW: 3(ChairmanMeow)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2008/53
2011 LHH 25U25: 3

3. Kyle Okposo(315*) BECAUSE HE'S DONE MORE
HIGH: 3(5)
LOW: 11(martylnd)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2006/7
2011 LHH 25U25: 4

4.Ryan Strome (315)
HIGH: 2(ChairmanMeow)
LOW: 14(shanamaj)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2011/5
2011 LHH 25U25: 5


5. Michael Grabner(305)
HIGH: 3(NDRE, AfroSupreme, Dougtone)
LOW: 12th(martylnd)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2006/14
2011 LHH 25U25: 2


6. Josh Bailey(290)
HIGH: 3(JPinVA)
LOW: 15(martylnd)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2008/9
2011 LHH 25U25: 8


7. Kevin Poulin(258)
HIGH: 4(BaltimoreIslander)
LOW: 17(BenHasna)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2008/126
2011 LHH 25U25: 7

8. Nino Niederreiter(250)
HIGH: 3(MikeKrugman)
LOW: 22(martylnd)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2010/5
2011 LHH 25U25: 6

9. Matt Martin(234)
HIGH: 6(captdallas, dougtone)
LOW: 16(martylnd, EDavidMorris)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2008/148
2011 LHH 25U25: 21

10. Matt Donovan(225)
HIGH: 3(martylnd)
LOW: 22(ChairmanMeow)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2008/96
2011 LHH 25U25: 13

11. David Ullstrom(210)
HIGH: 8(4)
LOW: 17(martylnd)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2008/102
2011 LHH 25U25: 19

12. Casey Cizikas(209)
HIGH: 9(shanamaj)
LOW: 15(2)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2009/92
2011 LHH 25U25: 16

13. Brock Nelson(207)
HIGH: 5(martylnd)
LOW: 18(ChairmanMeow)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2010/30
2011 LHH 25U25: 12

14. Calvin deHaan(199)
HIGH: 6(2)
LOW: 19(CaptDallas)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2009/12
2011 LHH 25U25: 10

15. Anders Nilsson(170)
HIGH: 8(Dougtone)
LOW: 24(martylnd)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2009/62
2011 LHH 25U25: 15

16. Kirill Kabanov(161)
HIGH: 6(NDRE)
LOW: 20(shanamaj)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2010/65
2011 LHH 25U25: 11

17. Aaron Ness(139)
HIGH: 12(ChairmanMeow)
LOW: 22(BenHasna)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2008/40
2011 LHH 25U25: OFF

18. Scott Mayfield(124)
HIGH: 8(martylnd)
LOW: OFF(shanamaj)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2011/34
2011 LHH 25U25: 18

19. Anders Lee(98)
HIGH: 9(martylnd, chairmanmeow)
LOW: OFF(NDRE, AfroSupreme, BenHasna)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2009/152
2011 LHH 25U25: 9

20. Rhett Rakhshani(82)
HIGH: 12(shanamaj)
LOW: OFF(NDRE,martylnd,BenHasna)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2006/100
2011 LHH 25U25: 22

21. Justin Dibenedetto(60)
HIGH: 13(BaltimoreIslander)
LOW: OFF(6)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2008/175
2011 LHH 25U25: OFF

22. Kirill Petrov(57)
HIGH: 13(shanamaj)
LOW: OFF(6)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2008/73
2011 LHH 25U25: 17

23. Johan Persson(42) *Because he's in North America
HIGH: 14(BenHasna)
LOW: OFF(5)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2011/125
2011 LHH 25U25: OFF

24. Johan Sundstrom(42)
HIGH: 19(NDRE, BenHasna)
LOW: OFF(5)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2011/50
2011 LHH 25U25: 20

25. Andrey Pedan(35)
HIGH: 20(martylnd, BenHasna)
LOW: OFF(6)
DRAFT YEAR/POS: 2011/63
2011 LHH 25U25: 24

DRAFT YEAR/POINTS/PLAYERS
2006/702/Okposo(315),Grabner(305),Rakhshani(82)
2007/0/Katic missed the list with 33 points.
2008/1832/Hamonic(359),Bailey(290),Poulin(258),Martin(234),Donovan(225),Ullstrom(210), Ness(139),Dibenedetto(60), Petrov(57)
2009/1051/Tavares(375), Cizikas(209), deHaan(199), Nilsson(170), Lee(98)
2010/618/Niederreiter(250), Nelson(207), Kabanov(161)
2011/558/Strome(315), Mayfield(124), Persson(42), Sundstrom(42), Pedan(35)

GENERAL OBSERVATIONS
1. Best draft value since the 2006 draft was Matt Martin. Martin was the 148th selection and has earned the 9th spot on this list ahead of at least 9 top 50 selections.
2. Only 6 defensemen made the list. 2 goaltenders made the list. Of the top 25 prospects under 25 years old, 17 were forwards. Only 2 defenseman were in the top 10. Only 1 defenseman on the list has played more than 10 games with the NYI. Where should their focus be in the 2012 draft?
3. 2007... Ryan Smyth... just sayin'
4. Some players that might make the team next year, even though they didn't make this list: Mark Katic, Ty Wishart, Mikko Koskinen.
5. Biggest moves from the 2011 LHH 25U25 (SEP 2011) to this consensus:
Matt Martin 2011=21,2012=9
David Ullstrom 19,11
Aaron Ness OFF, 17
Anders Lee 9,19
Ty Wishart 14, OFF