clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Islanders Power Ranking Survey

New, comments

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

This is an idea completely ripped off from the esteemed Capitals site Japers' Rink (which is not only a great site but also an inspiration for much thievery). So credit them for the idea and WebBard for suggesting we lift it.

Power Rankings are always funny to me: By nature, you're trying to guess who doesn't deserve the normal measure we use for teams (i.e., their record ... and that's not even getting into mikb's "real" record universe). So compiling power rankings can lead to interesting insight but also confounding confusion. (e.g. "Well I know this team is better than their record, but if I move them up then they'll be in sixth...and I don't know if I believe that...and now who do I move back?")

Then there is the whole diction: "Power." I'm pretty sure I was around when the first publication made "power rankings" for what surely wasn't hockey, but for the life of me I can't remember why that term was used. As in, "This team here? They've got lots of power. And that team over there? Well they had lots of power last week, but they have less power now. Is that clear?"

Regardless, here's the survey.

Note: Most of these were posted Oct. 18 (so before the Toronto game), but sadly there is no International Association of Power Rankings to decide which day of the week a publication compiles their rankings. So just keep in mind they won't always reflect the same moment in the schedule. Not that the voters can catch every game anyway.


Survey of Media Power Rankings

Outlet Rank Last Week Their Commentary
CBSSports (Oct. 18) 24 29 Never hurts to have a morale booster like being in first place to start a new week.
Col. Dispatch (Portzline, Oct. 18) 24 27 Not saying the Isles are good. But, like Edmonton in the West, they have nothing to lose this season and won't go away easy most nights.
ESPN (Oct. 18)
17 24 Josh Bailey (seven points in five games) has a message on behalf of his young Isles team: We're ready to win now!
Sportsnet (Brophy) 11 27 John Tavares returned to the lineup and scored a goal in the Islanders 5-2 win over the Avalanche.
Fox Sports (pts. %) 13(t) 23 Blake Comeau's two goals and three assists helped the Islanders collect five of the eight points that were on the table last week.
SB Nation (conf. rank) 5 13 The fact that the Isles have the record they do with the injuries they do is just remarkable.

So how does that look to you? Also: Any publications/ranking lists you'd rather see or would like added?



Because I saw and enjoyed them, and you might too:

  • Well, look at this: A Globe and Mail writer (Calgary-based Eric Duhatschek) observes how strange it is to see the Battle of New York being led by the Islanders. [Globe and Mail]
  • One view of how the Islanders handled John Tavares' head injury: Very conservatively. [Toronto Star]
  • If you didn't see Down Goes Brown's transcript of every hockey game ever broadcast, well it could be his best work yet. [Down Goes Brown]
  • This "Great Moments in Uncensored NHL Braodcasts" was delightfully unsafe for work. Warning: It does include the moment Rick DiPietro's life changed. [From the Rink]
  • This is old, but I found Chris Niel's comments on the Wisniewski incident interesting. [SLAM]
  • Since it came up yesterday, here was some of the coverage in Oshawa right after Calvin De Haan returned. [Oshawa Express] [Newsdurhamregion]
  • I'm just gonna say this story was what jinxed Josh Bailey's hip. []
  • Going through Toronto, DiPietro had to go through the "I'm healthy, happy to be here" drill with local media. [Star]