That toxic smoke you smelled yesterday was Maple Leafs fans burning down the internet after the team announced that not only would coach Randy Carlyle be returning for another year behind the bench but that he had also signed a two-year contract extension. Assistant coaches Dave Farrish, Scott Gordon and Greg Cronin (hey, those last two sound familiar) were let go.
The Leafs problems under Carlyle have been documented and discussed non-stop - lots of shots against and lots of goons balanced with some really good goaltending and a couple of good forwards. But GM Dave Nonis and new president Brendan Shanahan still feel that Carlyle has the team pointed in the right direction. They are wrong.
Nonis' recollection about how the Leafs season imploded is a fantasy, whether you put stock in underlying stats or not. The reasons the Leafs braintrust gave for bringing Carlyle back are full of contradictions and gaps in logic. The man's body of work is DOA, save for a couple of weeks last Spring. Even at his press conference, Carlyle admitted he had no idea why the Leafs season went sideways. That's not a good sign.
Regardless of the extension, Carlyle could still be fired if the Leafs falter again or a coach they want is made available. Who knows what the team will look like by then, once the roster is shaped to bring in players more attuned to Carlyle's style, whatever that is.
Maybe I shouldn't be throwing stones from a glass Nassau Coliseum. But this is sports and every team has problems and its our right to laugh and shake our heads at who we want to. The Islanders have a lot of issues, many of their own making that maybe wouldn't have happened if some different people had been driving the bus. They're just as guilty of harping on "battle level" (or "compete level" or "energy" or whatever) and everyone has a laundry list of things they need to change that somehow stay constant year after year.
But for all the resources and money and influence and unavoidable gravitational pull the Leafs have, it shouldn't be this hard for them to put a quality team together. They aren't bound by a lot of the shackles that other teams are. Instead of locking up third liners for multiple years and multiple millions or enabling Carlyle's quixotic quests, the Leafs should use their ample wealth and stability to devote more time and people to getting better without the restrictions other teams face.
In other words, if you can send an SOS to everyone in the world, why hang on for dear life on the first life preserver you see?
Other NHL news:
- Meet Matt Martin at the Islanders team store on May 22. Just don't touch his hair.
- Playoffs: The Bruins tied their series with the Canadiens with a 1-0 overtime win on Thursday night. Burrito enthusiast and Bruins farmhand Matt Fraser scored a little over a minute into OT. And the Ducks took their first home game of the series, 3-2 over the Kings.
- A loss in Pittsburgh tonight would end the Rangers' season. Filip Bondy lays the blame at the feet of Teflon Glen, who does just enough to keep Jim Dolan from asking questions.
- Plaxico Burress is much more accurate with his game predictions and Twitter zings than he is with firearms. [Slam Sports]
- Good isn't good enough for the Predators anymore. A new gear needs to be found. [Toronto Star]
- Speaking of the Predators, venerable SBN blogger Dirk Hoag is stepping away from On the Forecheck. His insights will be missed.
- Pensburgh goes deep inside Rob Scuderi.
- Bruins cheerleader and PROFESSIONAL NON-BASEMENT DWELLING SPORTSWRITER Joe Haggerty had some adventures in editing after Game 3 of the Bruins-Habs series. Haggs also has some enemies beyond the blogs. [WEEI]
- Yeah, this "fancy stat" isn't going to win any new fans in either community. THoR has no use for your Sidney Crosby or Alex Ovechkin. [Washington Post]
- ECHL playoffs: Stockton got back in their series with Bakersfield with a 6-2 win on Wednesday night. The Thunder trail 2 games to 1 going into Friday night's Game 4.
- NEW! Via Kulka's Korner, here's the TV schedule for the IIHF World Championships, which start today. Get to a TV at 1:30 pm for USa vs Belarus on NBCSN.
NYI captain John Tavares is back skating. He's on the ice right now with the London Knights as they prep for the Mastercard Memorial Cup.— John Shannon (@JSportsnet) May 9, 2014
- Islanders News: Generalisimo Halak still unsigned; Preparing for the Worlds; More Joensuu
- NHL News: Reinhart praise, coaching moves, AHL relocation, NBC bingo, dumping the dump and the chase
- [Bits] To Nabby or Not to Nabby; That is... A Question
- [Bits] Snow speaks; Kvasha encounter; Life at Barclays; Stockton down
- Garth Snow on Jaroslav Halak, Sebastian Collberg, Scott Mayfield, 'no restrictions' budget