Bits: For Modano, Weight, familiar endings loom
Neither Doug Weight nor Mike Modano have announced their retirement, but certainly signs point to "yes." Each has talked about it in recent months with the needle pointing toward "empty" for these USA Olympians, part of the star crew that won the 1996 World Cup.
I'm the type who never, ever says, "That guy should just retire already." Maybe that stems from a life spent loving and playing this sport (at meaningless levels) and experiencing the void when injuries hinder you or take you off the ice. To me, you've got one life, one health, one window -- so as long as you have the opportunity to play, you take it until you decide it's over. I figure that's what Weight's decision-making process has been about.
That said, this earned right of the player makes for tough endings for fans, in a "back of the hockey card" sense. Think of what the back of Mike Bossy's hockey card would have looked like had he struggled on through three more seasons truncated by back injuries. Or think of the bottom of Modano's card, which now tails off from 57 points, to 46, to 30 and then finally this awkward 15 in the funny red uniform.
As fans, we like tidy narratives that end well, "legacy" intact. Scenes like Willie Mays as a Met are forgotten. We like Dave Andreychuk to go out a storied Cup winner (finally!) in Tampa Bay, not as the guy who held on for one more year and retires mid-stream. More Lanny MacDonald or Jim Brown, less Brett Favre or Mark Messier.
But it's not our call. We can all see the writing on the wall. We can all hope our team doesn't make too big a bet on the health of an aging star. But it's hard to begrudge a guy for giving it every last try to play this child's game on its biggest stage. Sometimes it turns up roses. Usually it turns up Nieuwendyk.
And it's a familiar drill: For Weight -- who when healthy these last few years has looked better than Modano -- the end comes through a series of injuries (shoulder, back) that short-circuit every "best shape of my life" start. Worse for Modano, whose earnest attempt at a diminished role on a contender this season was sabotaged by a freak skate cut injury. Modano's been a healthy scratch these playoffs. For captain Weight, it never got that low.
So it went for Steve Yzerman (34 points in 2005-06 "on one knee"), for Keith Tkachuk (32 in 2009-10, with a major facial injury altering his final months) and so many others.
Bill Guerin lucked out both with health and in that his final seasons were spent on the wing of the league's top center, on a team that tried to use wingers on a budget. On any other team, Guerin doesn't pot 21 goals each of his final two seasons (combined minus-21), as underlined by his very end, when he wasn't re-signed and tried to land a training camp job in Philadelphia.
It can be painful to watch and easy to forget. But I don't blame these guys one bit.
Links
Tavares scored in Canada's shootout win over the U.S. (Conklin, not Montoya). [FanShot]
Meanwhile, in host Slovakia's game against their next-door rivals, history has never ever seen a more accurate headline, full stop.
The Coyotes live another year.
Sean Bergenheim joins a wonderful list of clutch unlikely playoff scorers. Patrick Flatley is a curious mention there (and is rightly labeled "not a surprise in retrospect"). Seeing Jim Campbell on there (no relation to the current villain) made me throw up. Eddie Johnston's quote on Dave Lowry is classic.
CHL Playoffs:
- Nino Niederreiter (who scored) and his Winterhawks won Game 1 of the WHL final in the first minute of OT. ... Good Yahoo preview of that series here.
- Casey Cizikas and the Majors lost Game 3 of the OHL final in the first minute of OT. Their series lead is at 2-1. More on the Game 2 of that series from Yahoo. ... Cizikas is up for the Trivino Award [FanShot]
- Meanwhile, in Kirill country, rumors still swirl about the fate of Kabanov's Lewiston team.
NHL and Such:
- The second round will last through the weekend, with the Canucks trying to close out the Predators tonight and the Red Wings avoiding elimination last night to force Game 5 Sunday.
- Raw Charge unveils the Dwayne Roloson "Get off my lawn" tee.
- Tim Connolly's report card at Die by the Blade. Heh.
- Behind the Net looks at the impact (if any) of extra rest in the playoffs.
- Carcillo is on Twitter.
- Down Goes Brown: Signs your second round is not going well.
- On the draft: Has Huberdeau faced tough enough competition?
Remember: Just because you're not Czech doesn't mean you can't be perfect, too.
8 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Test run on the updated signature
And this is one of the first tweets from Carcillo on his bad penalty in the clinching game and expanded on by PPP
where else would a cockroach live? RT "@OG_CarBomb13: Need to find a big rock to crawl under…f my life
Twitter for iPhone • 5/6/11 11:28 PM
Zing!
When the Isles make us drink, we curse Milbury through a monocle and with our pinkies out. Lighthouse Hockey & Chivas-All Class.
Website: Lighthousehockey.com Twitter: @KeithLHHhockey
by Keith Quinn on May 7, 2011 7:27 AM EDT via mobile reply actions
lol, if Carcillo actually mad his game less "toolish", he could actually be a very solid/above-average 4th liner. The man has some solid raw hockey skills (and above average fighting/hitting ability).
Proud Islanders fan, the organization that iced the greatest team to ever play the game, whom won 4 consecutive cups. I'm bleeding Blue and Orange.
Let's go Islanders! Beep...Beep...Beep.Beep.Beep.
Datsyuk IS the best player in the nhl
I was surprised to see Modano scratched in the playoffs
I was also surprised to see he didnt retire last year. It seemed like a perfect time to retire. He got a few game winning goals in the last few games, and ended the season in minnesotta. At the end he came out in a North Stars jersey. I thought that would be it, but its all about how he felt, and i guess he felt he had another year left in him.
If you spend your career with largely one team
It’s never a good idea to try continuing your career with another. So many players across so many leagues, it rarely ever ends well.
"And Campbell knows that if head-shots are eliminated, fighting must be eliminated too. Since fighting is, by definition, punching people in the head" - Quisp
Contributor to Lighthouse Hockey not sure if I'm the Sniper or the Enforcer.
It sounded like Ken Holland talked him into "one more Cup run"
And who knows, without the skate cut injury maybe it works out different. He’s one of those, I don’t think he realized how much he diminished in his final years, so I think he didn’t want to go out the way his final Stars years did.
Contrast with Roenick (who I forgot to mention here), who I think was more aware of his limitations and really fit a lower-line role in his final years in San Jose.
I’d wager Weight when healthy was more effective than either of them in his final years (skating being a big part of this), but of course his body would not stand up for more than a few games at the beginning of each season before something new happened.
Lighthouse Hockey: Stay classy, my friends. Er, stay thirsty, my brother. Aw hell, whatever.
the looming end
good article, some good points.
Nino is in the finals, wonder if he gotten any more "best" skater in the whl attention recently.
And to think, if he was born a week or 2 earlier he’d likely be the #1 pick/in the running for the #1 pick.
If Nino played a full season in the whl, his number “would” look something like this given his stats:
53goals/92pts
vs RNH’s 31goals/106pts, I think you’d have one hell of a running for the #1 pick, but I think Nino would take it. Elite goalscorers are better then elite playmakers, and then there is RNH’s size/nhl-readiness question. Oooooo what could have been. Nino is gonna be something really special, gotta think he has the 2nd highest ceiling of anyone on the team or in the system, next to Tavares. Won’t be too long till he’s potting 30goals+ a year and being that 2-way power forward we have been dreaming of. I can’t wait. lol
Proud Islanders fan, the organization that iced the greatest team to ever play the game, whom won 4 consecutive cups. I'm bleeding Blue and Orange.
Let's go Islanders! Beep...Beep...Beep.Beep.Beep.
Datsyuk IS the best player in the nhl

by 











































