Marian Hossa and the Demise of a Would-be Dynasty
Will The Kid ever get the glory back or are Cole Harbour's best days behind it?
about 2 years ago
BCISLEMAN
8 comments
0 recs |
Comments
Reading too much into it
I’m not really buying that the Pens’ loss this year is some sort of cap result — it’s not like they were a juggernaut to begin with. Did they miss Gill and Scuderi? Probably, but they had younger guys they wanted to take their place anyway.
Meanwhile, the razor-thin loss to Montreal wasn’t a product of lacking defense (well, with the exception of multiple inexplicable defensive brainfarts in Game 7 by guys who should know better).
The cap is definitely a challenge for them now and in the next few years, but so is the fact that playoff series are hard, and only one team can win it all each year.
Lighthouse Hockey: Playing the NHL Lotto
I think the piece is right about Hossa though
Not a good move for them. They should have focused more on developing their own talent. Building a dynasty or even a dominant franchise like the Devs or the Wings takes patience.
That was a risky move
I guess it paid off — they got a run to the finals, Esposito’s injuries continued, and Christensen has been weak as ever — but yeah, that was a big price, and he walked. And they won the Cup without him anyway. It smacked of rushing their rebuild. I hope the Isles don’t do that when they start to get close; they can afford rentals even less that Pittsburgh.
Lighthouse Hockey: Playing the NHL Lotto
I guess its knowing when the right time comes
to make a Goring-type move. Of course, Anders might prove to be our Goring. If he has enough AP and DL credits, maybe he graduates from ND in 2013. If he does spend a year by invitation in Oxford, maybe he’s with us for the 2014-15 season. Isles patiently waited for Kenny to finish his four years…and then look what happened.
On that note, going back to their defense
I’m probably too simplistic to say it’s not cap-caused. I mean, the cap is what forced them to place their bets on the young D over the departing free agents in the first place, so of course that’s a big factor.
But that bet may even prove to be good; they had a good team this year, they might have an even better team next year (or in two years) if those guys improve while Gill and Scuderi decline. Hard to project. With that much money tied up in Crosby and Malkin they’re always going to have that challenge. I just thought that article made it sound a little too much like they’d built this great team that the cap tore apart.
Lighthouse Hockey: Playing the NHL Lotto
I expected Ponikarovsky to work out much better for them, especially with the chance to play next to Malkin. Boy did that fall short.
Ironically, their best wing was the one they spent the most assets to get and who scored a lot in the playoffs without actually winning the Cup. So it goes.
Lighthouse Hockey: Playing the NHL Lotto













































