Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: My First Fight: Diego Sanchez

Islanders 5, Blackhawks 3: Roloson shines, Niemi/Huet stumble, Comeau hat tricks

This is a script only the mischievous hockey gods could draw up: Take season-long rumblings that the very talented Blackhawks cannot go all the way with their goaltending. Throw in a mostly excellent season from the rumored-about Dwayne Roloson, nearing the end of his career but capable of carrying a team. Conspire to have these two teams have their only meeting on Trade Deadline Eve.

The rest is obvious: Roloson stands on his head stopping 41 shots for a completely overmatched squad, and Antti Niemi and Cristobal Huet team up in a show of LOLtending that makes Joel Quenneville's head explode. It was Roloson's eighth 35-or-more-save performance of the year.

Game Sum. | Event Sum. | Corsi | Recaps: nhl.com | Isles



Oh, also: Blake Comeau, who never had a mutli-goal game before February, scores his first NHL contract.

Not to rain on a delightful result, but the rest of the Islanders really were awful tonight. The puck was constantly in their zone, several stretches of 5-on-5 looked like a Hawks powerplay, and as a matter of fact, the Hawks weren't called for a single penalty. Corsi is hardly the end-all, be-all, but seriously: Look at these figures. It was as if they were told to showcase Roloson by allowing a Hawks shooting gallery. At one point, Roloson showed off by playing without his stick. As if to say: "Hey, Chi-town. Can your goalies do this?"

Star-divide

What's wild is a very similar Isles theft happened last season when the Islanders visited Chicago, in a 40-save Peter Mannino display that would seem to underline how goaltending can have a much bigger psychological and tangible impact than it reasonably ought to. I mean, last year it was just Mannino, who's back in the AHL this year. But the message, as we rush headlong into the final hours of the NHL silly season, is that the Hawks could waste a year of their championship-caliber window by heading into the playoffs with goaltending that could fall apart.

Of course that's the maddeningly immeasurable part of proverbial "playoff" goaltending, isn't it? Average goalies have won before, average goalies will win again. Anyone can get hot or rise to their peak for six weeks in front of a good team. But as soon as that goaltending looks, well, average, the plague of doubt floods the team, the coaching, the management, the media and the fans (and Jeremy Roenick, of course). Everyone can feel it.

The killer for the Hawks is, you could acquire a guy like Roloson and ride him all the way to finals only to have disaster strike like it did to then-Oiler Roloson in 2006. Or, you could do the same and your normally stellar new goalie could be just average. Like Martin Brodeur vs. Carolina average. Even Roberto Luongo vs. Chicago (or Team USA) average. You just never know.

Game Highlights


Comeau's Career Night

But it would be wrong to only chuckle at the Chicago effects of this game when the victory would not have been possible without Comeau's hat trick. Richard Park and Jon Sim's goals were goofy, but Comeau took a nice Rob Schremp Hockey-forced turnover (the first of two Schremp assists) for the first goal and shot two top-shelfs for his second and third. I don't know if he took shooting practice over the break or if it was just more subtle effects of the Niemi/Huet experience, but it was nice. It was the kind of shooting you hope to one day again see from John Tavares.

Happy Note

As Marty noted in the game thread: Hey, one win down, only 14 to go in the final 19 to gain a potential playoff bubbly 88 points. No sweat. But on the realistic bright side, this win matches their win total from last year and brings them within a point of the 61 compiled during last year's 30th-place finish. Funny what a little progress and :cough: goaltending can mean.

Comment 10 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Here's a thought

Roly has a $2.5 cap hit and Chicago is rumored to want to move Versteeg with a $3 cap hit. Roly and Blake to Chi for Versteeg and their first rounder.

by BCISLEMAN on Mar 2, 2010 11:04 PM EST reply actions  

Wow...

I originally though the picture at the top was Sutton in a Senators uniform already. Those Blackhawks uniforms look a LOT like the Sens.

Please NBC, Fire Milbury, Hire Roenick Full time!!!

by Mark D on Mar 2, 2010 11:25 PM EST reply actions  

Olympic hockey overrated?

Does anybody else think the Olympic tournament has been overrated in terms of the quality of hockey? I felt that already during the last week and do so even more after tonight’s action around the league. But I’m honestly unsure, as so many players and analysts have spoken highly of the Olympic tournament…

Overall it might have been a cool event indeed. The matchups were great, the atmosphere was special and so on. But was that equally the case for what we saw on the ice? I just have the feeling I’ve seen so many players do better, have more jump, do the little things more properly, etc. throughout the season compared to last week. I don’t blame the players, obviously, it’s tough to build chemistry without any practices and it’s tough to play at noon. They surely played hard every shift and made the most of it, but was that really all that sensational?

In terms of intensity out there, I’ve however liked some of tonight’s games – including parts of the Islanders game – better than most of the games last week.

by BenHasna on Mar 2, 2010 11:30 PM EST reply actions  

I do think it's overhyped a bit

But I also think it’s just … different. It’s tournament hockey, the motivation is different, and the context for upsets and favorites is different. So there can be bad games and classic games in a different way than regular season NHL hockey. Similar to how college hockey is different, actually.

Honestly, the reason I like NHL hockey so much vs. any other league or level is it’s the best possible athletes/talents/bodies there are with (theoretically) the best possible coaching. Night in, night out, that’s just hard to beat.

Lighthouse Hockey: Under contract through 2021, knees and hips be damned.

by Dominik on Mar 2, 2010 11:35 PM EST up reply actions  

Not sure I agree

Drury and Streit, for example—esp Drury were playing as well or better than usual. Sometimes players and teams turned in stinkers, but mostly it was very good hockey. And the rule about a major and a game misconduct for headshots and fighting didn;t spoil it for me at all Grapes and Maclean!!!

by BCISLEMAN on Mar 3, 2010 2:07 AM EST up reply actions  

Roloson rumors, of sorts

Don’t want to do a separate post on this as it’s just conjecture, but some late-night musings from HNIC’s Elliotte Friedman’s Twitter:

Garth Snow could be a major player tomorrow. NYI apparently considering taking Cristobal Huet’s deal from Chicago as they will need to…stay at cap floor. Chicago will make it worthwhile. Question though: which goalie are they targeting in return? Roloson? Or, maybe….Tomas Vokoun? Huet cap hit $5.625. Vokoun $5.7. If CHI doesn’t want a NYI goalie, Snow could deal elsewhere for more picks/prospects. … Snow never leaks anything, though. Respect that about him, but it’s tough to figure out for sure.
So yeah, there’s that theory.

Lighthouse Hockey: Under contract through 2021, knees and hips be damned.

by Dominik on Mar 2, 2010 11:57 PM EST reply actions  

If there's anything to it

it does make it interesting. With Huet’s cap hit gone, there’s no need to move Versteeg. Hawks have two second rounders: theirs and Calgary’s. Isles send Roly to Chi for Huet and their first and one of their seconds. Isles then deal Biron to Flyers for their third rounder.

by BCISLEMAN on Mar 3, 2010 2:02 AM EST up reply actions  

Comeau into his own?

It would really be nice to see Blake finish strong. Schremp makes a nice pilot to his bombardier. Add Joensuu or Martin to the mix when Sim is gone and that is a nice, young second line.
Which brings up another point. Has Sean of the dead become the new Thumbellini. It’s starting to look as though neither of the pending RFA’s are going to be LW’s of the future for this club. I guess I wouldn’t be surprised if either was traded today. I’d hate to see Bergy get sliced, but with Bailey seeming more at home on the wing, and Moulson playing his way into an extension it’s hard to see them keeping both next year. Bergy is way more valuable as he plays an energetic shift, has been solid on the PK in the past and seems to work in the aggressive forecheck mode. He just hasn’t shown the hands of a consistent scorer.
All this leads me to believe that Snow will try to make a deal for one of them today. They need a LARGE defensive prospect who is buried somewhere. Rolo/Bergenhiem to Washington for Carlson? I’d rather give up Tambellini, but I have a feeling there wouldn’t be too many takers. Streit shouldn’t be playing 26 minutes, with heavy PK mins. They need a banger back there.

by JPinVA on Mar 3, 2010 2:37 AM EST reply actions  

Awful?

Methinks your judgment is too harsh, Dominik. While there were certainly awful stretches I thought some guys were playing better than they were right before the Olympic break (see Hunter, who seemed to have a little more verve than he has in a long time [even despite missing that empty-netter toward the end]) and for those few minutes at a time where they were really on the ball they looked like the hockey team they should be in a few years.

The Isles were definitely helped out by goal tending on both ends of the ice and got a few freebies (Hossa had an uncharacteristically flubby night) but I also saw a lot of little things the Isles themselves did right and I found it heartening. My confidence in the team is restored even if I’m still not expecting 30 more points.

by ilopan on Mar 3, 2010 7:45 AM EST reply actions  

I’d grant some little things here and there. And I saw a lot of pleased reactions from people who were at the game. But for me, remove a brief stretch of quick Islanders goals and you had a team that was outplayed all night long.

I know Chicago is one of the best in the league, but the way they handled their third-period lead was depressing.

Lighthouse Hockey: Under contract through 2021, knees and hips be damned.

by Dominik on Mar 3, 2010 10:57 AM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

A New York Islanders blog for fans near and far. Hip and shoulder surgery not required.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

890_1__small
The defenseman that could be... +POLL

Recent FanPosts

Small
2012 Playoffs - Its time to take the next step.
Small
Isles Missing Grit, Not Toughness
X-wing_small
Time to Sell on Evgeni Nabokov
Small
No toughness
Kevinwriterpic_small
2012 NHL Draft Prospect Profile: Matt Dumba
Small
Reeser Out 2-3 Weeks, Who's next?
One_smith03_small
Nielsen and Tavares Happily Drink the Kool-Aid! So What's Our Problem with UFA's?
Small
Would Milbury have drafted Tavares?
Kevinwriterpic_small
2012 NHL Draft Prospect Profile: Nail Yakupov

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Featured Poll

Poll
Garth Snow screwed this one up because he should have:

  305 votes | Results

Isles Reading

Atlantic Standings

GP W L OTL PT
New York Rangers 55 37 13 5 79
Philadelphia 56 31 18 7 69
Pittsburgh 56 32 19 5 69
New Jersey 56 32 20 4 68
New York Islanders 56 24 24 8 56

(updated 2.15.2012 at 8:59 AM EST)

New York Islanders Roster

# Pos. DOB W H
Josh Bailey 12 LW 10/2/1989 190 6-1
Rick DiPietro 39 G 9/19/1981 190 6-1
Mark Eaton 4 D 5/6/1977 215 6-1
Michael Grabner 40 RW 10/5/1987 185 6-0
Travis Hamonic 3 D 8/16/1990 203 6-2
Milan Jurcina 27 D 6/7/1983 253 6-4
Andrew MacDonald 47 D 9/7/1986 196 6-1
Matt Martin 17 LW 3/8/1989 210 6-3
Al Montoya 35 G 2/13/1985 203 6-2
Mike Mottau 10 D 3/19/1978 190 6-0
Matt Moulson 26 LW 11/1/1983 205 6-1
Evgeni Nabokov 20 G 7/25/1975 200 6-0
Aaron Ness 55 D 5/18/1990 170 5-10
Nino Niederreiter 25 RW 9/8/1992 205 6-2
Frans Nielsen 51 C 4/24/1984 184 6-0
Kyle Okposo 21 RW 4/16/1988 205 6-0
Jay Pandolfo 29 LW 12/27/1974 190 6-1
P.A. Parenteau 15 LW 3/24/1983 193 6-0
Marty Reasoner 16 C 2/26/1977 205 6-1
Dylan Reese 42 D 8/29/1984 201 6-1
Brian Rolston 11 LW 2/21/1973 215 6-2
Steve Staios 24 D 7/28/1973 200 6-1
Mark Streit 2 D 12/11/1977 197 6-0
John Tavares 91 C 9/20/1990 202 6-0
Tim Wallace 36 RW 8/6/1984 207 6-1
Ty Wishart 6 D 5/19/1988 222 6-4
Calvin de Haan 44 D 5/9/1991 187 6-1

Blog Bossy

Lhh-square_small Dominik

Enforcers & Snipers

Warlord2_small Mark D

Lighthouse_hockey_logo_2_medium_small Keith Quinn

Tubby_goalie_gif_small mikb

Hg_small Chris McNally

Master of FIGs and Power Tablature

Icon3_small ICanSeeForIslesAndIsles

Emeriti

Officials_sweater_1_small IslesOfficial

Headshot_small Michael Schuerlein

71096_479208120482_1257968_n_small David Hanssen