Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Notre Dame's Turnaround: How Have The Irish Done It?

Returning from the woods, still voting Tavares

So I'm back from a pretty amazing trip to the Czech Republic, spent mostly in a remote (and not-quite Internet connected) village that was my father's hometown, and I've just sifted through news to learn what I missed: Everything and nothing.

The Canadiens were sold to someone who doesn't sing bad sappy songs in Vegas, Jim Balsillie was turned back (again), the Isles hired a new assistant coach, and Garth Snow still isn't tipping his hand to what he will do come Friday night.

The following is something I truly respect about Garth Snow's approach:

"Honestly, and this isn't an indication of who we're taking or not taking, but we can't be concerned with public perception of what people think we should do," Snow said. "We owe it to our fans and ourselves to draft the player who we think gives us the best chance to win the Stanley Cup one day. That's the only consideration we have. That's all that matters."

That said, I'm very curious to know how Snow and staff determined, before the lottery -- and since confirmed by them afterward -- that a specific one of the top three prospects gives them the best shot at winning the Cup one day.

Maybe they see something in Matt Duchene that is otherworldly in character and leadership. Maybe they subscribe to a theory of championships built around cornerstone defensemen. But with the standard caveat that I'm not a scout, I'm not sure how they've determined one is a better bet than any other, and under those conditions I'd still vote for the star who will make an immediate impact both on and off the ice.

Of course, in the end these are but teenagers. And the Isles staff knows far more about these uncertain teenagers than I do, never having had them over for a slumber party or watched their every junior (or SEL) move. If Snow and company go with a non-consensus pick, I'll stand by -- and eagerly await the moment five years down the line when that pick really starts to pay off. Such is the position of the die-hard fan.

Stay tuned for much more draft coverage here and around SB Nation hockey blogs. (On that note: A big thanks to Doug/IslesOfficial for keeping things running here while I was in the figurative boonies. Look for more from him here and at his NYI Official's Outlook blog.) It's a big moment in the Isles history, and we'll be documenting it in between episodes of panic about the future.

Comment 4 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Tough position. The easy answer is Tavares – given his offense – but building on a foundation which a kid such as Hedman may provide is difficult to turn away, from a franchise standpoint.

Easy answer: Tavares can help to make The Lighthouse a reality.

by Donny Rivette on Jun 21, 2009 11:51 PM EDT reply actions  

Easy answer: Tavares can help to make The Lighthouse a reality.

I always hesitate to say that (“What, a teenager altering a civic development question?”), but 1) There was that Kid Crosby, and 2) Given the political nature of the project’s fate, if Islanders fans start paying greater attention and flocking to the Coliseum, it will have an effect.

With Hedman, the thing that pushes me away is that franchise D have proven to be harder to project. The thing that scares me is that 6’6", smooth-skating blueliners are hard to get around.

Lighthouse Hockey: Side effects may include Weight gain and frequent game loss.

by Dominik on Jun 22, 2009 1:58 AM EDT up reply actions  

First, let me say this: “You’re welcome, Dom! It was my pleasure.”

Second, let me go into what I’m thinking as of yesterday’s Newsday article by my pal Logie.

It can be said at this point, now 4 days away from the inevitable (and 1 from when the Isles management team heads to Montreal), that Garth Snow and his scouting/draft staff are some of the best poker players on the planet and should consider a career change after this is all over. Fueled by fan opinion dread the consensus has bounced from Tavares to Hedman to now Duchene over the past two months and still no one even has the slightest inkling of what the Islanders will do. That in itself is a triumph of this Draft. Let me provide a quote from Snow as evidence:

"The best player we and the staff identified could be different from public opinion,‘’ Snow said. "We held Josh Bailey in higher regard than what others did last year. Our focus was to select a player who could help us win the Stanley Cup.’’

Setting everyone up for an eventual pick of Duchene or Hedman or a last minute ploy to get the bidding started for the 1st overall pick…?

Whichever way this goes, Garth has played his cards right to the end. Now when it comes to showdown, will he be able to rake in that pot or will he beat himself and lose it all?

4 days….tick, tock, tick, tock…

From the Penalty Box to the Blog Box! Check it out at Isles Official's Outlook!

by IslesOfficial on Jun 22, 2009 9:48 AM EDT up reply actions  

Garth Snow and his scouting/draft staff are some of the best poker players on the planet and should consider a career change after this is all over.

No doubt. It’s pretty amazing what they’ve managed in the poker arena. Whether it does anything other than create buzz, I don’t know, but at least their options are wide open. If TB or Col happen to want a specific player, he’s certainly given them reason to squirm.

Lighthouse Hockey: Side effects may include Weight gain and frequent game loss.

by Dominik on Jun 22, 2009 10:53 AM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

A New York Islanders blog for fans near and far. Hip and shoulder surgery not required.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

890_1__small
The defenseman that could be... +POLL

Recent FanPosts

Kevinwriterpic_small
Dreger: Parenteau Shelves Contract Talks Till After Season
Small
2012 NHL Mock Draft #1
Small
2012 Playoffs - Its time to take the next step.
Small
Isles Missing Grit, Not Toughness
X-wing_small
Time to Sell on Evgeni Nabokov
Small
No toughness
Kevinwriterpic_small
2012 NHL Draft Prospect Profile: Matt Dumba
Small
Reeser Out 2-3 Weeks, Who's next?
One_smith03_small
Nielsen and Tavares Happily Drink the Kool-Aid! So What's Our Problem with UFA's?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Featured Poll

Poll
Garth Snow screwed this one up because he should have:

  319 votes | Results

Isles Reading

Atlantic Standings

GP W L OTL PT
New York Rangers 55 37 13 5 79
Philadelphia 56 31 18 7 69
Pittsburgh 56 32 19 5 69
New Jersey 56 32 20 4 68
New York Islanders 56 24 24 8 56

(updated 2.15.2012 at 8:59 AM EST)

New York Islanders Roster

# Pos. DOB W H
Josh Bailey 12 LW 10/2/1989 190 6-1
Rick DiPietro 39 G 9/19/1981 190 6-1
Mark Eaton 4 D 5/6/1977 215 6-1
Michael Grabner 40 RW 10/5/1987 185 6-0
Travis Hamonic 3 D 8/16/1990 203 6-2
Milan Jurcina 27 D 6/7/1983 253 6-4
Andrew MacDonald 47 D 9/7/1986 196 6-1
Matt Martin 17 LW 3/8/1989 210 6-3
Al Montoya 35 G 2/13/1985 203 6-2
Mike Mottau 10 D 3/19/1978 190 6-0
Matt Moulson 26 LW 11/1/1983 205 6-1
Evgeni Nabokov 20 G 7/25/1975 200 6-0
Aaron Ness 55 D 5/18/1990 170 5-10
Nino Niederreiter 25 RW 9/8/1992 205 6-2
Frans Nielsen 51 C 4/24/1984 184 6-0
Kyle Okposo 21 RW 4/16/1988 205 6-0
Jay Pandolfo 29 LW 12/27/1974 190 6-1
P.A. Parenteau 15 LW 3/24/1983 193 6-0
Marty Reasoner 16 C 2/26/1977 205 6-1
Dylan Reese 42 D 8/29/1984 201 6-1
Brian Rolston 11 LW 2/21/1973 215 6-2
Steve Staios 24 D 7/28/1973 200 6-1
Mark Streit 2 D 12/11/1977 197 6-0
John Tavares 91 C 9/20/1990 202 6-0
Tim Wallace 36 RW 8/6/1984 207 6-1
Ty Wishart 6 D 5/19/1988 222 6-4
Calvin de Haan 44 D 5/9/1991 187 6-1

Blog Bossy

Lhh-square_small Dominik

Enforcers & Snipers

Warlord2_small Mark D

Lighthouse_hockey_logo_2_medium_small Keith Quinn

Tubby_goalie_gif_small mikb

Hg_small Chris McNally

Master of FIGs and Power Tablature

Icon3_small ICanSeeForIslesAndIsles

Emeriti

Officials_sweater_1_small IslesOfficial

Headshot_small Michael Schuerlein

71096_479208120482_1257968_n_small David Hanssen