Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: 2012 Budweiser Shootout Entry List Released

New scouting report as Tavares circus continues

I don't want this place to turn into The Daily Tavares -- really, I don't. But despite my Quixotic protests, it appears the media circus of ink around the young man will dominate from now until the Great Teenager Stalk Meet known as the NHL Entry Draft is over.

When it's not Brian Burke dropping blustery declarations of intent to get the hallucinating sector of Leafdom [see comments here] believeing he could be theirs, it's the least-common-denominator junkies in the Toronto media spouting effluvia to imply Canada's "best" junior player is their birthright who should start pulling a Lindros ('cause that worked out well). They also repeatedly traffic in innuendo about the Lindros question even when Tavares has said for the umpteenth time he won't commit that karmic suicide.

(Don't you love the idea that because the franchise you root for or cover is located in one of the league's largest, easy-revenue population centers, said club somehow deserves all the spoils of a league whose very existence depends on, you know, multiple teams? Talk about being born on third base thinking you hit a triple... In their view, other teams are but a nuisance and the Leafs should exist alone, apparently to feverishly beat themselves for the Cup each year.)

Remarkably, at least one Toronto media member was even upset at criticism from Chris Botta, just a "lowly" Islanders blogger (Who cares about the Islanders, anyway? Besides the thousands of fans and hyper-sensitive Toronto media members who are Botta's readers, I mean), for calling out some of his peers on their lethal Jonestown-level mix of kool-aid and sense of entitlement. Grow some thick skin already! You're bastions of the Hockey Black Hole Center of the Universe, right? A little jab from a connected Isles blogger ain't no thang ... is it?

Just as every fanbase has idiots and every arena has fools, every media corps has its tools: If you're not one of them, you should probably possess the self-awareness to know it, and chill accordingly.

And Now for Something Actually Relevant...

But that's all white noise -- background microwave radiation for a playoffless spring. Today something actually interesting and relevant was put forth about Tavares (who Garth Snow and Charles Wang will be watching tonight in person):

Newsday's Greg Logan has another read on the Tavares-Hedman-Duchene debate from Redline Report, a (ahem, paid) scouting service that has surely committed a crime by questioning the fallibility of Tavares.

In addition to favoring Hedman for our pet cornerstone two-way defenseman reasons, the report calls Duchene the more complete player and dismisses Tavares as "one-dimensional" and Brett Hull-like in effort and "even body [type]." (Wait, so JT is overweight?! Or he doesn't backcheck until threatened by Mike Keenan or locker room alpha dogs in Dallas and Detroit?) From Logan's excerpts, the report is rather hilariously detailed in its claimed knowledge of the kid (a bit extreme, if you ask me).

But interesting stuff nonetheless. I must note that I watched Hull's emergence and prime from my Midwestern perch and -- while I had a laundry list of criticisms for him -- I'd take "his kind" for the Islanders in a heartbeat. For all his eventually uncovered flaws, Hull was the perfect medicine to heal a Blues fanbase that had been through some very Islanders-like ownership messes.

The quickly developing meme about Tavares' playoff performance this season is also advanced in the Redline Report's um, report. I've watched as much OHL playoffs as I have Swedish elite league hockey, so I can't judge there. But if Tavares appears weaker than the hype of the last three years, I'll only offer this:

  • It's fair to wonder how being traded in the middle of the World Junior Championships has affected his integration with a new team.
  • It's fair to wonder how much three weeks should alter your impression of a player who has been followed and universally praised for the last 40 months.
  • It's fair to wonder about the scouting service's profit motive.

That's the crap-shoot of the draft (and the vultures who feed on it), of course. Projecting teenagers is like predicting the effects of puberty: You know something significant will happen; you don't know if you'll like the result. Either way, you're stuck with it, and God can be one sick prankster.

No matter how many people come along and say, "Come on you're crazy if you don't want Tavares" -- myself included -- ultimately we won't know what was right until 2016. So it's nice to hear another perspective on the kid's abilities -- and not more self-absorbed speculation about which market maximizes reporters' his earning potential.

Now if you'll excuse me, I hear there's a bearded lady to check out behind Ring 3. But I'm not sure about her heart.

Comment 2 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

I see what's going on

The way that everyone was trying to persuade poor John into thinking he NEEDS and WILL play for Toronto, how do you say, COMPLETELY FAILED. They have now moved onto phase two – the attempt at devaluing a player who has been touted to go number one for a LONG TIME,

The reasons you listed (re: his struggling playoff performance) are duly noted and honest to goodness reasons why a young man (with dreams of playing in the NHL, stresses of the looming draft and focus on his playoff performance) are ALL valid.

Sure, this isn’t the toughest part of the kids Major Junior career, nah – not in the least.

Islesblogger is a contributor to Lighthouse Hockey: SBN's New York Islanders blog who's lost the most man games to injury.

by Michael Schuerlein on Apr 20, 2009 6:28 PM EDT reply actions  

I love it

I swear this “oh, he was invisible down the stretch” idea comes about every draft year, too. You hype someone for so long, you’ve got to change the narrative a bit to keep people buying in.

Your devaluation note occurred to me, too. Like, “ooh, if they can talk him down to a #3 ranking, maybe he’s within Burke’s reach after all.”

Lighthouse Hockey: Side effects may include Weight gain and frequent game loss.

by Dominik on Apr 20, 2009 6:40 PM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

A New York Islanders blog for fans near and far. Hip and shoulder surgery not required.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

890_1__small
The defenseman that could be... +POLL
Small
Isles Missing Grit, Not Toughness
X-wing_small
Time to Sell on Evgeni Nabokov
Small
No toughness
Kevinwriterpic_small
2012 NHL Draft Prospect Profile: Matt Dumba
Small
Reeser Out 2-3 Weeks, Who's next?
One_smith03_small
Nielsen and Tavares Happily Drink the Kool-Aid! So What's Our Problem with UFA's?
Small
Would Milbury have drafted Tavares?
Kevinwriterpic_small
2012 NHL Draft Prospect Profile: Nail Yakupov
Capt
10 Game Chunk #5: Playing Like a Playoff-Bound Team Would

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Featured Poll

Poll
Garth Snow screwed this one up because he should have:

  265 votes | Results

Isles Reading

Atlantic Standings

GP W L OTL PT
New York Rangers 54 36 13 5 77
Philadelphia 56 31 18 7 69
Pittsburgh 56 32 19 5 69
New Jersey 55 31 20 4 66
New York Islanders 55 23 24 8 54

(updated 2.14.2012 at 3:50 AM EST)

New York Islanders Roster

# Pos. DOB W H
Josh Bailey 12 LW 10/2/1989 190 6-1
Rick DiPietro 39 G 9/19/1981 190 6-1
Mark Eaton 4 D 5/6/1977 215 6-1
Michael Grabner 40 RW 10/5/1987 185 6-0
Travis Hamonic 3 D 8/16/1990 203 6-2
Milan Jurcina 27 D 6/7/1983 253 6-4
Andrew MacDonald 47 D 9/7/1986 196 6-1
Matt Martin 17 LW 3/8/1989 210 6-3
Al Montoya 35 G 2/13/1985 203 6-2
Mike Mottau 10 D 3/19/1978 190 6-0
Matt Moulson 26 LW 11/1/1983 205 6-1
Evgeni Nabokov 20 G 7/25/1975 200 6-0
Aaron Ness 55 D 5/18/1990 170 5-10
Nino Niederreiter 25 RW 9/8/1992 205 6-2
Frans Nielsen 51 C 4/24/1984 184 6-0
Kyle Okposo 21 RW 4/16/1988 205 6-0
Jay Pandolfo 29 LW 12/27/1974 190 6-1
P.A. Parenteau 15 LW 3/24/1983 193 6-0
Marty Reasoner 16 C 2/26/1977 205 6-1
Dylan Reese 42 D 8/29/1984 201 6-1
Brian Rolston 11 LW 2/21/1973 215 6-2
Steve Staios 24 D 7/28/1973 200 6-1
Mark Streit 2 D 12/11/1977 197 6-0
John Tavares 91 C 9/20/1990 202 6-0
Tim Wallace 36 RW 8/6/1984 207 6-1
Ty Wishart 6 D 5/19/1988 222 6-4
Calvin de Haan 44 D 5/9/1991 187 6-1

Blog Bossy

Lhh-square_small Dominik

Enforcers & Snipers

Warlord2_small Mark D

Lighthouse_hockey_logo_2_medium_small Keith Quinn

Tubby_goalie_gif_small mikb

Hg_small Chris McNally

Master of FIGs and Power Tablature

Icon3_small ICanSeeForIslesAndIsles

Emeriti

Officials_sweater_1_small IslesOfficial

Headshot_small Michael Schuerlein

71096_479208120482_1257968_n_small David Hanssen